THE
MARXIST-LENINIST RESEARCH BUREAU
Report No. 11
THE ALEKSANDR SMIRNOV CASE
(1928-38)
The Formation of the Smirnov
Group (1928-29)
In February 1928, Aleksandr
Smirnov*, who had been People's Commissar of
agriculture in the Russian Republic, was promoted to the position
of Secretary of the Central Committee of the CPSU:
"In February (1928 - Ed.), the Rightist Commissar of
Agriculture of the Russian Republic, Aleksandr Smirnoy, was . . . appointed
to the Party Secretariat".
(Stephen F. Cohen: 'Bukharin and the Bolshevik Revolution:
A Political Biography: 1888-1938'; London; 1974; p. 279).
and shortly afterwards Smirnoy took the initiative in forming
an opposition group. At his public trial in March 1938, the defendant Izaak
Zelensky*, a former agent of the tsarist secret service,
admitted:
"I joined the Right organisation at the end of 1928 or
at the beginning of 1929, . . . I was recruited by A. P. Smirnov".
(Izaak A. Zelensky: Testimony at 1938 Treason Trial,
in: Report of Court Proceedings in the Case of the Anti-Soviet 'Bloc of
Rights and Trotskyites' (hereafter listed as 'Report (1938)') ; Moscow;
1938; p. 325).
The A. P. Smirnov group:
"was Bukharinist in economic outlook".
(Stephen F. Cohen: op. cit.; p. 348)
but separate from the Bukharinist leadership:
"The top Rightists . . . refused to have anything to
do with Smirnov's plans."
(Robert Conquest: 'The Great Terror: Stalin's Purge of
the Thirties'; London; 1968; p. 31).
Their programme included
the dissolution of most collective farms, the idependence of the trade
unions from Party leadership and the removal of Stalin from the post of
General Secretary of the CPSU:
"Their (the A. P. Smnirnov group's - Ed.) programme seems
to have covered . . . the dissolution of most of the kolkhozes, . . . the
independence of the trade unions. Above all, they had discussed the removal
of Stalin".
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 30).
The defendant Izaak Zelensky
admitted at the 1938 treason trial that the programme of the A. P. Smirnov
group also included wrecking and terrorism:
"At the end of 1931 or the beginning of 1932, Smirnov
. . . told me of the new tactics which had been outlined by the centre
of the Rights, and which consisted in the following: the use of double-dealing,
a conspirative form of organisation, the adoption of tactics of wrecking,
diversion, destruction, training insurrectionary cadres, the adoption of
terrorism."
(Ivararokion;, Zelensky: Testimony at 1938 Treason Trial,
in: Report (1938); op. cit.; p. 327).
From the outset, the A. P. Smirnov group was underground
and illegal:
"Smirnov's group . . . decided to go underground and
formed an independent group known as 'Bolshevik Workers . .. His first
efforts were devoted to the creation of illegal cells in the more important
working-class centres and the drawing together of all oppositional elements
within the Party".
(Abdurakhman Avtorkhanov: 'Stalin and the Soviet Communist
Party: A Study in the Technology of Power'; Munich; 1959; p. 193).
"A. P. Smirnov's group . . . had to a large extent gone
underground, with a view to organising for a struggle".
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 30).
Among prominent members of the A. P. Smirnov group were Nikolay
Uglanov* (discussed in the paper on the Ryutin
Affair) and Lev Karakhan* -
later exposed as a German agent, as was admitted by defendants in the 1938
treason trial:
"RYKOV: Karakhan reported that the German fascists were,
of course, very well disposed towards the prospect of the Right coming
into power and would welcome it very much".
(Report (1938): op. cit.; p. 179).
"VYSHINSKY: Accused Bukharin, were you aware that Karakhan
was a participant in the conspiratorial group of Rights and Trotskyites?
BUKHARIN: I was.
VYSHINSKY: Were you aware that Karakhan was a German spy?
BUHARIN: No, I was not aware of that.
VYSHINSKY (TO RYKOV): Were you aware, accused Rykov, that
Karakhan was a German spy?
RYKOV: No, I was not.
VYSHINSKY: Were you not aware that Karakhan was engaged
in negotiations with certain German circles? .
RYKOV: Yes, yes.
VYSHINSKY: Treasonable negotiations?
RYKOV: Treasonable. .
VYSHINSKY (TO BUKHARIN): Were you aware that Karakhan
was engaged in negotiations with the German fascists?
BUKHARIN: I was. .
VYSHINSKY: Did you endorse these negotiations?
BUKHARIN: . . . I did not disavow them; consequently I
endorsed them.. . . .
VYSHINSKY: And so, accused Bukharin, you bear responsibility
for these negotiations with the Germans?
BUKHARIN: Undoubtedly".
(Report (1938): op. cit.; p, 401-02, 407, 408).
The importance of the A. P. Smirnoy affair lay, firstly,
in the fact that it embraced senior officials who had never before been
associated with any opposition:
"The views of A. P. Smirnov and his followers mark an
important crux. For we find veteran senior officials who had never been
associated with any opposition".
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
and, secondly, in the fact that it:
"was supported by important trade union officials".
(Abdurakhman Avtorkhanov: op. cit.; p. 192.
The CCICCC Resolution on the
A. P. Smirnov Affair (1933)
In January 1933, the A.P. Smirnov group was condemned
at a joint plenary meeting of the Central Committee and Central Control
Commission of the Party. Bukharin dissociated himself from the group:
"At the plenum, Bukharin . . . made a speech typical
of the extravagant and insincere tone which was now conventional in ex-oppositionist
statements, demanding 'the severe punishment of A. P. Smirnov’s grouping."
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
A resolution of the Plenum charged the group with forming
an underground opposition group:
"Smirnov and others in fact carried on anti-Party activity
and opposed the Party policy. They established a factional underground
group".
(Resolution of Joint Plenary Session of Central Committee
and Central Control Commission, CPSU (January 1933), in: Abdurakhman Avtorkhanov:
op. cit.; p. 194).
"At the January 1933 plenum , . . . the last of the new
cycle of plots was exposed. . . . A. P. Smirnov . . . was charged . . .
with forming an anti-Party group".
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
"The group of . . . A. P. Smirnov . . . was discussed
at the meeting of the Central Committee and the Central Control Commission
in January 1933. A resolution was adopted condemning the creation of an
underground factional group, allegedly dedicated to the disruption of industrialisation
and collectivisation and the restoration of capitalism".
(Roy A. Medvedev: 'Let History Judge: The Origins and
Consequences of Stalinism'; New York; 1971; p.155).
"In January 1933, still another underground opposition
cell was unearthed, this one organised by the former Commissar of Agriculture,
A. P. Smirnov, . . . They were accused of organising 'bourgeois degenerates'
to attempt, like the Ryutin
group, 'the restoration of capitalism and in particular of the kulaks."'
(Robert V. Daniels: 'The Conscience of the Revolution';
Cambridge (USA); 1960; p. 380).
Nevertheless, the members of the group:
"were treated leniently".
(Ian Grey: 'Stalin: Man of History'; London; 1979; p.
256).
The Plenum removed Smirnov from the Central Committee:
"The joint plenary session of the Central Committee and
Central Control Commission therefore resolves to expel Smirnov from the
Party Central Committee with a warning that if he fails to gain the confidence
of the Party in his work, he will be expelled from the Party".
(Resolution of Joint Plenary Session of the Central Committee
and the Central Control Commission (January 1933). in: Aburakhman Avtorkanov:
op. cit.; p. 195).
"Smirnov was removed from the Central Committee, with
a warning that expulsion from the Party would follow if his future work
did not merit trust."
(Roy A. Medvedev: 'Let History Judge: The Origins and
Consequences of Stalinism'; New York; 1971; p.155).
"A. P. Smirnov and others. . . . were merely reprimanded
by the Central Committee, not expelled from the Party. Smirnov, the only
one who had been on the Central Committee, was removed from it and threatened
with expulsion from the Party if he did not mend his ways."
(Robert H. McNeal: 'Stalin: Man and Ruler'; Basingstoke;
1988; p. 146).
"A. P. Smirnov (was expelled -- Ed.) from the Central
Committee.'"
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
The Expulsion and Trial of A.
P. Smirnov (1934-35) In December 1934.
Nonetheless Smirnov was expelled from the Party in 1934:
"Smirnov was expelled from the Party in December 1934
. . . for double-dealing and continuing his struggle against the Party".
Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
Early in 1935 Smirnov was arrested, tried for and found guilty
of anti-Soviet activity and sentenced to imprisonment. He died in imprisonment
in 1938.
The Trials of Uglanov and
Karakhan (1936-37)
In 1936,
". . Uglanov and others were given jail sentences."
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 31).
while Karakhan was tried in 1937 for treason, found guilty
and executed:
"On 16 December (1937-- Ed.) . . . Karakhan . . . and
others had been tried before the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court
as spies, bourgeois nationalists and terrorists, had confessed and had
been executed".
(Robert Conquest: op. cit.; p. 272).
Published by: THE MARXIST-LENINIST RESEARCH BUREAU,
Ilford, Essex,
BIOGRAPHICAL NOTES
KARAKHAN, Lev N., Soviet revisionist lawyer and diplomat
(1889-1937); RSFSR People's Commissar of Foreign Affairs (1918-20, 1922);
USSR Ambassador to china (1923-26); USSR Deputy People's Commissar of Foreign
Affairs (l93~ 34); USSR Ambassador to Italy (1934-37); arrested, tried
for and found guilty of espionage and treason, sentenced to death and executed
(1937).
SMIRNOV, Aleksandr P., Soviet revisionist politician (1877-1938);
RSFSR People's Comissar of Agriculture1 and simultaneously Secretary-General,
Peasants' International (1923-28); RSFSR, Deputy Premier (1928-30); Secretary,
Central Committee, CPSU (1928-30); expelled from Party (1934); arrested,
tried for and found guilty of anti-Soviet activity and sentenced to imprisonment
(1935); died in imprisonment (1938).
UGLANOV, Nikolay A., Soviet revisionist politician (1886-1940);
secretary, Petrograd Party Committee (1921-22); secretary, Nizhny Novgorod
Party Committee (1922-24); secretary, Moscow Party Committee (1924-28);
USSR People's Commmissar of Labour (1928-30); expelled from Party (1932);
reinstated in Party (1934); re-expelled from Party, arrested, tried for
and found guilty of anti-Soviet activity, and sentenced to imprisonment
(1936); died in imprisonment (1938).
ZELENSKY, Izaak A., Soviet revisionist politician (1890-1938);
Secretary, Moscow Party Committee (1920-21, 1924-31); Secretary, Central
Asian Party Bureau (1924-31); Chairman, Central Union of Consumer Co-operatives
(1931-37); arrested (1937); tried for and found guilty of treason, sentenced
to death and executed (1938).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
AVTORKHANOV, Abdurakhman: 'Stalin and the Soviet Communist
Party: A Study in the Technology of Power'; Munich; 1959.
COHEN, Stephen F.: 'Bukharin and the Bolshevik Revolution:
A Political
Biography: 1888-1938'; London; 1974.
CONQUEST, Robert: 'The Great Terror; Stalin's Purge of
the Thirties'; London;
1968.
DANIELS, Robert V.: 'The Conscience of the Revolution';
Cambridge (USA); 1960.
GREY, Ian: 'Stalin: Man of History'; London; 1979.
McNEAL, Robert H.: 'Stalin: Man and Ruler'; Basingstoke;
1988.
MEDVEDEV, Roy A.: 'Let History Judge: The
Origins and Consequences of Stalinism'; London; 1972.
ISCHULZ, Heinrich E., URBAN, Paul K. & LEBED, Andrew
I. (Eds.): 'Who was Who in the USSR: 'Biographic Dictionary'; Methuen (USA);
1972.
Report of Court Proceedings in the Case of the Anti-Soviet
'Bloc of Rights and Trotskyites'; Moscow; 1938.
FOR OTHER MARXIST LENINIST
RESEARCH BUREAU STUDIES ON SOVIET ESPIONAGE CASES:
KIROV
RYUTIN
SMIRNOV
SYRTSOV-LOMINADZE
AFFAIR
"INDUSTRIAL
PARTY'
GO TO ALLIANCE:
SUBJECT
INDEX
GO TO ALLIANCE:
CATALOGUE
GO TO ALLIANCE:
"WHAT'S
NEW PAGE";
GO TO ALLIANCE: HOME
PAGE ALLIANCE